Commentary on The Real
Estate Website Industry
Since
1997 I have monitored the activity in the real estate website
industry. This was, and is, my industry. I was observing my
competition. I watched as companies came into the industry, many
with multi-million dollar funding, and began selling websites to
Realtors. I was able to quickly perceive that the websites they
were selling would not generate significant business for the
Realtors. Within two years most of these companies were either
out of business or had been bought out by yet other companies.
What was happening here?
These
companies were successful initially because they were offering
Realtors what the Realtors believed they needed, websites. And,
they were selling the sites at bargain prices. But, after a
year, without realizing any revenue from the sites, many
Realtors canceled their contract with these companies. It wasn’t
long before most of these early real estate website companies
disappeared. The more recent entries into this field have done
better but they are still selling cheap websites. Only now they
explain to the Realtors that for their cheap websites to produce
revenue they must spend more money. They make the process seem
simple and they quote costs that are unrealistically low. They
sell the Realtors optional services that make the sites produce
some activity. But, the “sites” still do not produce the results
that they might.
I
estimate that more than 300,000 Realtors have bought “cheap”
websites. Among this group of Realtors there are some that have
achieved significant results from their websites but, this is a
very small number.
These
companies have created a large group of Realtors who are
disenchanted with the Internet. The Realtors believe that they
have done all that should be done to be successful on the
Internet. But, they have not realized the income that they
expected from their Internet marketing. Many have ended up
spending incredible amounts buying traffic and leads from yet
other companies who are feeding on the Realtors needs.
Here
is an example
This company sells it’s
basic website for $699. There are several options such as an
IDX/MLS package and an e-mail program that drive the cost up to
$1,499. It then offers another optional package that it prices
at $2,495 for search engine optimization. But, then it explains
that there are other costs involved with this package making the
estimated total for this option $5,000. Within these extras is
an annual budget of $1,000 for pay per click engines. Now,
anyone with knowledge of Internet marketing knows that $1,000
will only buy 600 to 800 clicks from real estate keywords. This
level of traffic is a good volume for one month not for a year.
At the same time this company recommends that the realtor “buy”
links on a number of real estate directories that have thousands
of Realtors listed. There is little value in this. At this point
the Realtor has spent $6,499. not including the monthly hosting
of the site at $39.95. So, the total is now $6,978.40 for the
first year.
What
is the real cost of Successful Internet Marketing?
The
reality is that a reasonable starting budget for the first year
is $12,000. This will produce almost immediate activity
resulting in leads and a potential to generate sales activity
within the first three months. It is possible to utilize a first
year budget of $5,000. to $7,000 but this will not generate
immediate activity and probably would not result in sales
activity until the last half of the year. It is important to
note that a large part of the first year investment is the
creation of the website and the initial setup. This investment
will produce results for the Realtor over a period of years. So
this investment must be amortized over at least three years.
Now we
really have to look at the marketing cost over a period of three
years. If we assume an initial set up cost of $6,000 and
amortize that over three years it breaks down to $2,000 per
year. Basic hosting should cost no more than $240 per year. The
Realtor should budget at least $400 per month for a combination
of pay per click and other traffic promotions. We should include
some regular reporting on the website activity and fine-tuning
of the site itself. This can run $500 per year. Add these
figures and we have a figure of $7,540 as a raw minimum cost.
For most Realtors this represents the commission on two to three
sales.
What
is the Typical Sales Profile for a Successful Internet Realtor?
A
Realtor just starting out on the Internet is dealing with a
“spin up” time that will slow down the development of his
Internet sales activity. On the one hand is the time it takes to
develop the exposure on the search engines and directories. It
takes six to twelve months to achieve top positions in the
organic search results. Secondly, most home buyers visiting
websites have plans to purchase a home more than six months
down the road. This means that it will take the Realtor 12 to 18
months to fill the pipeline.
In the
first year utilizing a serious marketing campaign a Realtor can
expect to achieve a transaction volume of eight to fifteen
sales. The second year will see the transaction volume increase
to twenty to thirty sales. All this assumes the Realtor is
diligent in following up the leads and is an effective sales
person.
Summary
Most of
the companies in the real estate website industry continue to
utilize a marketing strategy based upon low prices without any
guarantee of results. Today we see companies selling websites
priced between $399 and $699. These are do-it-yourself templated
websites that the Realtor is expected to complete himself. The
companies offer extensive instruction and technical support for
the Realtors but, fail to explain the whole story. The companies
withhold significant knowledge that allows them to sell
additional services to the Realtor. The result is a large group
(thousands) of Realtors who do not achieve significant success
with their websites.